17 Old-Fashioned Cakes That’ll Keep Everyone Coming Back for More

There’s something special about old-fashioned cake recipes—they bring a sense of nostalgia and a taste of simpler times. This collection of 17 classic cakes features timeless favorites like German Chocolate Cake, Crumb Coffee Cake, and Devil’s Food Cake. Whether you’re baking a rich Lemon Chiffon Cake, a seasonal Eggnog Cake, or a crowd-pleasing Pumpkin Bundt Cake, these recipes capture the charm and flavor of traditional baking. Perfect for family gatherings or just because, these cakes are a delicious way to honor the past while creating new memories.

Banana Pudding Poke Cake

Photo credit: The Cookie Rookie

Get ready for the ultimate taste of summer with this Banana Pudding Poke Cake! It’s a fluffy yellow cake loaded with banana pudding and topped with a layer of whipped cream. And, of course, we’re sprinkling crumbled vanilla wafers on top to give you that classic banana pudding vibe in every bite. So good, you’ll want seconds!
Get the Recipe: Banana Pudding Poke Cake

Lemon Chiffon Cake

Image Credit: Baking A Moment

Easy Lemon Chiffon Cake: Light, airy, and perfectly sweet with a bright citrusy kick. It’s moist, fluffy, and perfect for sharing with a crowd!

Get The Recipe: Lemon Chiffon Cake

German Chocolate Cake

Photo credit: Handle the Heat

Get ready to whip up the most indulgent German Chocolate Cake ever! This tender, delicious cake topped with that classic coconut-pecan frosting is going to be your new favorite.
Get the Recipe: German Chocolate Cake

Crumb Coffee Cake

Hey, cinnamon fans! You’re going to love this Crumb Cake recipe. Imagine a moist, tender cake topped with a thick layer of sweet, cinnamon-y crumble. It’s cozy, delicious, and guaranteed to hit the spot.

Get The Recipe: Crumb Coffee Cake

Boston Cream Pie Cake

This Boston Cream Pie Cake is everything we love about classic American desserts! Think moist cake layers, a creamy vanilla filling, and a rich chocolate glaze on top. It’s the kind of nostalgic treat that never disappoints—and always hits the spot.

Get The Recipe: Boston Cream Pie Cake

Chocolate Fudge Cake

Got a packed schedule but still craving something sweet? This easy sheet cake is here to save the day! It’s quick to whip up and topped with a rich, glossy chocolate frosting. The perfect no-fuss treat to satisfy your sweet tooth!

Get The Recipe: Chocolate Fudge Cake

Old-Fashioned Chocolate Brownies

Hey chocolate lovers! These brownies are next-level—super fudgy and packed with extra chocolate chips for the ultimate double-chocolate treat. You’re going to be obsessed!

Get The Recipe: Brownies

Lemon Pound Cake

This lemon pound cake is bursting with citrusy goodness! Made with fresh lemon juice and zest, it’s super moist, buttery, and packed with sunny flavor in every bite. And the best part? That tangy lemon glaze on top—it’s the perfect finishing touch!

Get The Recipe: Lemon Pound Cake

New York Cheesecake

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

Ready to wow everyone with a creamy, crack-free New York-style cheesecake? This foolproof recipe is so easy, even beginners can nail it. Get baking and impress your friends!

Get The Recipe: New York Cheesecake

Pumpkin Bundt Cake

You’ve got to try this Pumpkin Bundt Cake! It’s topped with a creamy dulce de leche icing and is absolutely perfect for cozy fall get-togethers.

Get The Recipe: Pumpkin Bundt Cake

Devil’s Food Cake

Warning: This Devil’s Food Cake is sinfully delicious! Its rich, fudgy texture and intense chocolate flavor are practically irresistible. Slice at your own peril – it might vanish before you know it!

Get The Recipe: Devil’s Food Cake

Coconut Lovers Dream Cake

Image Credit: Erren’s Kitchen

If you love coconut, this moist cake is a must-try! Packed with shredded coconut and rich coconut flavor, it’s topped with creamy frosting and toasted coconut flakes—a treat for both your taste buds and your eyes.

Get The Recipe: Coconut Lovers Dream Cake

Red Velvet Bundt Cake

Craving an easy show-stopping cake? This red velvet cake is perfectly moist and topped with creamy cheese icing that’s simply irresistible. Perfect for birthdays, dinner parties, or a weekend treat. Get ready to impress!

Get The Recipe: Red Velvet Bundt Cake

Homemade Yellow Cake

Soft, buttery, and oh-so-moist, this classic yellow cake is made from scratch and tastes way better than any box mix out there!

Get The Recipe: Homemade Yellow Cake

Orange Cake

This Ultimate Orange Cake is packed with citrusy goodness! It’s made with fresh orange juice and zest for loads of flavor, and the crunchy orange glaze on top gives it an extra zesty kick in every bite.

Get The Recipe: Orange Cake Recipe

Eggnog Cake

Who says eggnog is just for the holidays? This Eggnog Pound Cake is packed with cozy spices and creamy eggnog flavor, all topped with a festive eggnog glaze. It’s like a slice of holiday cheer whenever you’re in the mood!

Get The Recipe: Eggnog Cake

Copycat Hostess Cupcakes

Photo credit: The Cookie Rookie

Take charge of your snack game with these Copycat Hostess Cupcakes! They’re so much better than anything you’ll grab at the store, and the best part? They’re super easy to make. Go on, give it a try!
Get the Recipe: Copycat Hostess Cupcakes