17 Old School Desserts That Still Steal the Show

This site runs ads and generates income from affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.

There’s nothing quite like old school desserts that bring back the sweet nostalgia of childhood and family gatherings. This collection of 17 classic dessert recipes is a delicious tribute to the timeless treats that never go out of style. From rich and fudgy chocolate Sheet Cake to comforting Banana Bread and the creamy delight of Boston Cream Pie Cake, these desserts are perfect for any occasion. Whether you’re craving the simple joy of Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies or the unique twist of Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake, these recipes are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth with a taste of the past.

Chocolate Sheet Cake

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

This chocolate sheet cake is rich, moist, and full of deep chocolate flavor. A hint of coffee elevates every bite, making it unforgettable. Topped with whipped ganache frosting, it’s the perfect treat for any chocolate lover!

Get The Recipe: Chocolate Sheet Cake with Whipped Ganache Frosting

Homemade Strawberry Pie

This strawberry pie is pure summer in every bite—juicy, sweet berries overflowing in a golden, buttery crust that’s perfectly flaky. A splash of citrus brightens the flavors, while a sprinkle of sugar on top adds the perfect touch of sparkle and sweetness.

Get The Recipe: Homemade Strawberry Pie

Homemade Strawberry Pretzel Salad

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

Strawberry pretzel salad is a beloved dessert that brings a taste of nostalgia to the table with a classic Midwestern and Southern American treat from the mid-20th century. The dish combines sweet, salty, and creamy flavors, with layers of crunchy pretzel crust, tangy cream cheese filling, and juicy strawberry topping.

Get The Recipe: Homemade Strawberry Pretzel Salad

Banana Cream Pie

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

This Banana Cream Pie is pure dessert bliss! Imagine layers of fresh, sweet bananas, velvety pastry cream, and fluffy whipped topping, all resting on a buttery, homemade crust. It’s the ultimate cool and creamy treat that brings a touch of nostalgia and a whole lot of love to every bite.

Get The Recipe: Banana Cream Pie

Applesauce Bread

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

This recipe is like a warm hug in dessert form—moist, tender, and spiced with just the right amount of warm cinnamon and sweet applesauce. For that extra pizzazz, toss on some cinnamon sugar for a crunchy finish that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance!

Get The Recipe: Applesauce Bread

Strawberry Shortcake Biscuits

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

This super simple recipe for Strawberry Shortcake Biscuits is made from scratch, so don’t be surprised when you discover that store-bought just can’t compete! Once you give this a whirl, those pre-packaged impostors will be a thing of the past! 🍓✨

Get The Recipe: Strawberry Shortcake Biscuits

Brown Sugar Cake

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

Bored with the same old bundt cake? Spice things up with this Brown Sugar Bundt Cake! It’s got a dense, tender crumb that practically throws a flavor party with rich brown sugar, topped off with a buttery caramel glaze that’s more decadent than your last vacation. Trust us, this is one sweet adventure you definitely don’t want to miss!

Get The Recipe: Brown Sugar Cake

Boston Cream Pie Cake

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

This Boston Cream Pie Cake is like a sweet hug from America itself! With moist cake layers cradling a creamy vanilla center and draped in a decadent chocolate glaze, it’s a nostalgic delight that promises to satisfy your sweet tooth and your heart. Who needs therapy when you have cake?

Get The Recipe: Boston Cream Pie Cake

Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

Ditch the chill time and say goodbye to waiting! These outrageous chocolate chip cookies are a speedy delight—mix, bake, and indulge in under 30 minutes. It’s like a cookie miracle! 🍪✨

Get The Recipe: Easy Chocolate Chip Cookies

Apple Turnovers

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

These puff pastry apple turnovers are like a cozy hug for your taste buds, blending apples and cinnamon into a crispy masterpiece. Perfect for breakfast or dessert—who says you can’t have your pastry and eat it too?

Get The Recipe: Puff Pastry Apple Turnovers

Blondies

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

Step aside, brownies! These golden beauties are here to steal the spotlight with a fabulous twist on the classic fudgy delight. With a texture so dense, you’ll question if they’re secretly weightlifters! Don’t miss out on this tasty upgrade!

Get The Recipe: Chocolate Chip Blondies

Crumb Coffee Cake

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

Attention all cinnamon fanatics! Get ready for your dream come true with this Crumb Cake recipe. Picture a moist, tender cake crowned with a lavish blanket of sweet, spiced cinnamon sugar crumble. It’s the kind of warm, inviting flavor that’ll have your taste buds dancing like nobody’s watching!

Get The Recipe: Crumb Coffee Cake

Award Winning Banana Bread

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

This award-winning recipe promises banana bread so moist, soft, and tender, it might just make you consider renaming it “Hug in a Loaf.” It’s a guaranteed hit that will quickly become your recipe box’s new favorite celebrity! 🍌🎉

Get The Recipe: Award Winning Banana Bread

Toffee Bars

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

Get ready to indulge in these Easy Salted Toffee Bars, where gooey toffee meets a delightful crunch—it’s a textural party in your mouth! Finished with a sprinkle of salt, these bars are so good they should come with a warning: dangerously addictive! This simple recipe will have you creating a dessert that steals the spotlight faster than you can say, “seconds, please!”

Get The Recipe: Easy Salted Toffee Bars

Lemon Pound Cake

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

This lemon pound cake is basically a citrus serenade! Infused with zesty lemon juice and zest, it’s so moist and buttery that it practically melts in your mouth, delivering a sunbeam of flavor with every bite. And the cherry on top? A delightful lemon glaze that brings this sweet symphony to a perfect encore!

Get The Recipe: Lemon Pound Cake

Coconut Cream Pie

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

This Creamy Coconut Custard Pie is your passport to vacation vibes without the hassle! Imagine rich custard and delightful coconut dancing together in a creamy filling, all crowned with a fluffy whipped cream wig. It’s a dessert that steals the show but won’t steal your time—deliciously simple!

Get The Recipe: Coconut Cream Pie

Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake

Image Credit: Erren Hart/Erren’s Kitchen

Don’t let the name throw you off – this Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake is a chocolate lover’s dream! It’s so moist it could win a hydration contest! No wonder it’s a fan favorite; who knew mayo could be such a sweet sidekick?

Get The Recipe: Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake